ePub Black Girl Dangerous on Race; Queerness; Class and Gender by Mia McKenzie in History

Review

2 of 2 people found the following review helpful. A Defiant and Powerful BookBy Leah E HallBlack Girl Dangerous is a collection of work from writer Mia McKenzie’s blog and website. Each piece offers a reaction to personal observations; conversations; and current events that represent broader social disparities from the writer’s perspective. BGD is a powerful contemporary work of social dissidence; central in which is a focus on the roles gender; race; class; and sexual identity play in forming an individual’s sense of self-worth; personal freedom; and social agency.Spoiler: If you’re a person of privilege who feels a little fussy about marginalized people speaking up for themselves; BGD will be an uncomfortable read. It might; though; prove to be the perspective-altering reality check you most need.Mia McKenzie allows her own experiences as a queer person of color to illustrate the ways in which inequalities permeate into the most intimate and defining aspects of a person’s identity. McKenzie’s works were written for an online audience between 2012-2014 and typically have an implied assumption that readers are up-to-speed on the news stories or social movements that are central to her discussion. For this reason; McKenzie’s commentary is to be understood at times within the specific context that it was written; as an immediate and unapologetic response to an evolving event or discussion. Some of the most compelling moments in BGD are those in which McKenzie strives to empower others who; like her; experience multiple layers of discrimination and exclusion. The tenderness with which she speaks about self-love as an act of resistance is both inspiring and heart-wrenching. For the most part; though; this collection can be characterized as a determined affront to the ways in which white people earnestly deny their own privilege while they dominate every position of power; every conversation; and justify excluding; devaluing; and erasing the lives of people of color. McKenzie uses highly controversial topics; such as the Newtown shooting; to expose the hypocrisy of white liberals; and includes tongue-in-cheek instructions on how to oppress white people as a way of illustrating the fallacy of “reverse-racism”. In this aspect; BGD is set apart from any other collection or essay I have ever read. Potentially; the confrontational tone present in some of the book might be interpreted as resorting to “call-out” rhetoric; further disengaging those to whom the criticisms are intended. McKenzie; in fact; addresses this critique and defends her approach in one of the selections. There remains to me; however; a small degree of ambiguity on this point. Ultimately; this book provides a sound voice of clarity in a society that remains constantly embroiled in tensions created by systematic inequalities. The direct and unpretentious manners in which topics related to women; gender; and sexuality studies are explored with depth also makes Black Girl Dangerous a useful teaching tool for students and activists. My own perspective having been dramatically expanded; I would definitely recommend this book.2 of 2 people found the following review helpful. An Alternative to Traditional Feminist TextsBy Amanda JonesAMJ - Mia McKenzie’s Black Girl Dangerous is an anthology of journal-like entries which were originally posted on the author’s personal blog; which was of the same name as the book; as a sort of activist performance of breaking the silence. It is a collection of selected entries; which are paired with the author’s retrospective analyses of the original posts and responses. Each entry consists of a short synopsis of events which the author noted via personal encounters; social media; and national news networks; as well as a personal analysis of those events as they pertain to issues of gender; sexuality; and race through the lens of a queer Black feminist. As a WGSS student; I found the book to be very insightful and provoking through its presentation of an intersectional alternative to the traditional heteronormative White feminism which has often been taught in WGSS courses. I also found it to be helpful and inspiring through its exemplification of a tangible version of feminist activism which is most feasible and effective in the digital age of the 21st century. Additionally; the author’s ability to be reflective and self-critical at times within the book is quite refreshing. I especially liked the entries in which the author called out her own friends and communities; questioning their responsibility in perpetuating some of the issues that are discussed. I felt that it offered a more realistic vision of feminism which acknowledged humans as imperfect and ever-changing beings; rather than flawless idols of social justice and moral upstanding. Overall; its greatest strength is its authenticity; specifically its conversational tone and personal approach. It makes feminism more appealing and far less intimidating in a world where the “F” word has been stigmatized. However; this same strength is the greatest weakness of the book; too. While the book provides an excellent example of realistic everyday feminism; it does not provide scholarly research based conclusions. Due to the nature of the writing style; there are not citations or references to solid statistics; studies; definitions; or concepts that are pivotal to any functional feminist study; discourse; or practice of WGSS subjects. Additionally; the information provided is primarily opinion based and must always been assessed with consideration to the author’s biases. This relates to another issue; which McKenzie herself mentions in the opening of the book: it does not include the dialogue and commentary amongst readers of the entries on the blog. Therefore; the response that the entries elicited is not fully understood; the discursive context in which certain things were said is lost; and the progression of ideas which is often achieved through open responsive dialogue is unavailable. Alone; the book simply does not hold up; it can only really be appreciated if some prior familiarity to concepts and events are present.Ultimately; it is a worthwhile investment for anyone studying WGSS. Although it does not establish a foundation for feminism; it does function as a rare example of ways in which feminism can be expanded; personalized; and critiqued.0 of 0 people found the following review helpful. A Powerful Voice Against SilenceBy CustomerIt is very rarely that one finds a book that is both equally as passionate and educational as Mia McKenzie’s Black Girl Dangerous. This book is a compilation of her blogs based off of her Tumblr page that soon grew wildly popular and not only expanded to a broad range of readers but also quickly accumulated other brilliant writers who joined her movement of breaking silence. Mia McKenzie’s writing is the embodiment of intersectionality and her book should be required for any WGS class; any sociology class; or basically just any class in general because so much can be learned from every one of her pieces. The best part of this book is Mia McKenzie’s writing style. She is straightforward; brutally honest; and combines educational writing with sarcasm which is highly effective in getting her points across. Her strength in writing is evident as all of her pieces transition effortlessly from originally being created in a blog format to gracefully presenting themselves on pages of a book. The pieces calling out white privilege are also one of the strongest parts of the book. I have never read a book that calls out and explains white privilege as honestly and unapologetically as she does. I think every white person should read her sections about privilege because the way she addresses it is much more powerful than any definition based; watered down version of white privilege found in any sociology or women’s study text book. In her essay about allyship; she claims that we have lost genuine allies because we refuse to address privilege and become an ally to selflessly support the individual instead of one’s own self-image or personal agenda to eliminate acclaimed ‘white guilt’. This book is a much needed space to honestly call out privilege and call in those who are willing to put their own selfishness aside and learn how to check privilege and become an actual ally. And throughout discussing the racism; homophobia; and misogyny in the world Mia McKenzie still reminds readers that one cannot forget to love themselves nor others facing the same struggles. A beautifully powerful message to the LGBTQ community when the rest of society deems any deviation of white; sexually hetero-normative love as evil. In order to understand anything about women’s studies; one must realize that we have to break out of the old school; cookie-cutter mode of feminism created by white; middle class women. We must introspectively examine the issues that EVERY woman is facing due to the white; straight patriarchal powers because if we are to truly embrace solidarity that means shedding the armors of white privilege and socially accepted; dominate stories. Black Girl Dangerous is a breath of fresh air from “non-offensive” textbooks because it addresses what must be addressed and in a way that it needs to be called out—in utter; unfiltered truth. Being that a lot of women studies spaces are still dominated by white; heterosexual or cisgender women; this book is crucial into seeing studies on intersectionality and true equality being spoken on and played out in the real world. I highly recommend this book and for anyone who claims to be a feminist or interested in women’s gender and sexuality studies; it is a must read.